Your IT Department

Why main contractors are asking their subcontractors for Cyber Essentials

Why main contractors are asking their subcontractors for Cyber Essentials

You are halfway through a PQQ for a decent-sized contract. Insurance details, accreditations, policies, references. All fairly familiar.

Then you hit the question:

“Do you hold Cyber Essentials certification?”

You don’t.

So why does the main contractor care about the security settings on your laptops, Microsoft 365 accounts and firewall?

There is a fairly sensible reason.

Cyber Essentials for subcontractors is increasingly being used as a straightforward way for larger organisations to check that businesses in their supply chain have basic cyber security controls in place.

It does not mean every subcontractor in Britain is legally required to have Cyber Essentials. They aren’t.

There is, however, an important difference between something being required by law and being required if you want a particular piece of work.

With a contract sitting on the other side of the question, the distinction becomes rather less academic.

Why are main contractors asking for Cyber Essentials?

Large contractors have a problem.

They can put considerable effort into securing their own systems, while still working with dozens, hundreds or sometimes thousands of other organisations.

The image shows an assessor from Your IT department helping a subcontractor through their cyber essentials certification.

Subcontractors receive drawings and specifications. They exchange commercially sensitive information. Or access project portals. They communicate with the main contractor’s employees. They may process personal information or hold credentials giving them access to shared systems and cloud services.

The main contractor’s exposure therefore extends beyond its own network and employees.

A cyber attacker does not particularly care which company in that chain has its name above the site entrance. If a smaller supplier provides an easier route to useful information or systems, that can be the more attractive target.

The National Cyber Security Centre’s guidance on securing your supply chain describes Cyber Essentials as a tangible way for organisations to gain confidence that suppliers and other third parties have implemented fundamental technical controls.

Procurement teams are looking for exactly that sort of reassurance.

Nobody expects a subcontractor with 30 staff to have the security operation of a multinational bank. They do, reasonably enough, want evidence that obvious routes into the business have been dealt with.

Cyber Essentials provides a recognised baseline.

This helps explain why Cyber Essentials tender requirements are appearing in supply chains involving main contractors, tier-one contractors, councils, housing associations, public-sector organisations and framework agreements.

Requirements vary between customers and contracts. You need to know what your particular buyer is asking for.

Cyber Essentials for subcontractors: is it mandatory?

No. Cyber Essentials is not a universal legal requirement for UK subcontractors.

That is worth stating clearly because the legal and commercial requirements are easily confused.

There is no general law saying a construction subcontractor must hold Cyber Essentials because it employs people, uses computers or works on construction sites.

A customer can, however, make certification a condition of working with them.

In practice, Cyber Essentials can therefore become a requirement for accessing a particular customer or opportunity, even though there is no general law requiring you to hold it.

You may encounter it through:

  • pre-qualification questionnaires
  • tender documentation
  • approved supplier schemes
  • supplier onboarding
  • framework applications
  • contract renewals
  • customer security questionnaires

If the buyer requires Cyber Essentials and you cannot provide it, you may not qualify.

A perfectly competent subcontractor can find itself excluded from an opportunity because somebody reaches a line on the PQQ asking for a certificate the business has never previously needed.

Much better to discover that six months before the tender than six days before the deadline.

What about public-sector contracts?

This is one area where precision is important.

The Government’s PPN 014: Cyber Essentials Scheme applies to central government departments, executive agencies, non-departmental public bodies and NHS bodies.

For certain contracts with characteristics that create higher cyber security risk, those organisations must ensure appropriate controls are in place. Suppliers can be required to hold Cyber Essentials or Cyber Essentials Plus before contract award, or demonstrate that equivalent controls are in place.

Other public-sector organisations can also choose to follow the approach.

So the claim that “Cyber Essentials is mandatory for all public-sector work” goes too far.

If public-sector work forms part of your growth plan, however, you should expect cyber security requirements to feature in procurement.

Many subcontractors will never contract directly with the public body either. The requirement can travel through the supply chain from client, to main contractor, to subcontractor.

By the time the question reaches your PQQ, its origins might be several contractual relationships further up the chain.

What about defence and MoD supply chains?

Defence deserves separate treatment because the requirements can go considerably further than obtaining a Cyber Essentials certificate.

The Ministry of Defence’s current Cyber Security Model uses a risk-based approach for the defence supply chain.

Under Cyber Security Model version 4, MoD Delivery Teams conduct risk assessments which determine a Cyber Risk Profile. Defence Standard 05-138 specifies controls associated with those profiles, suppliers complete Supplier Assurance Questionnaires, and relevant requirements can flow down to subcontractors.

Cyber Essentials can be useful evidence of baseline security, but it should not be treated as an automatic answer to every defence cyber security requirement.

If you are bidding into an MoD or defence supply chain, check the requirements attached to the particular contract rather than assuming the Cyber Essentials certificate covers everything.

What are the five Cyber Essentials controls?

Cyber Essentials focuses on five technical control areas:

  1. Firewalls
  2. Secure configuration
  3. Security update management
  4. User access control
  5. Malware protection

Five headings sounds reassuringly manageable.

In practice, each one reaches into the everyday way you manage IT.

Firewalls

The requirement focuses on controlling traffic between your organisation’s devices and the internet.

This can cover the firewall protecting your office network or equipment providing internet access at another business location.

Female Cyber Essentials assessor showing a client their Watchguard firewall in the server rack

Having a router in a cupboard isn’t enough. It needs appropriate configuration, unnecessary inbound access needs removing and administration needs protecting.

That forgotten remote-access setup created three years ago because somebody needed to “quickly get onto something from home” may deserve another look.

Secure configuration

Computers, mobile devices, applications and services often arrive with features, accounts and settings you don’t actually need.

Cyber Essentials requires organisations to reduce unnecessary exposure.

In practical terms, this includes sensible configuration, removing or disabling unnecessary accounts and services, changing default or easily guessable credentials and avoiding unnecessary administrative access.

Your estimator’s laptop probably doesn’t need every piece of software installed on it since 2019.

Even if Dave still uses one of them occasionally.

Security update management

Software vulnerabilities are discovered constantly. Once a vulnerability becomes known, leaving vulnerable software in use gives attackers something specific to target.

Software within the Cyber Essentials scope must be supported by the vendor.

There is also a specific timescale for certain vulnerability fixes.

IASME’s current guidance on vulnerability fixes says fixes must be applied within 14 days of release where the vendor describes the vulnerability as critical or high risk, where it has a CVSS v3 score of 7 or above, or where the vendor does not provide details of the severity of the vulnerabilities addressed.

Automatic updating should be enabled where possible.

Translated into normal business language: supported software and timely security updates are part of achieving certification.

The ancient laptop kept in a drawer because “it still works” can cause considerably more trouble than its book value would suggest.

User access control

People should have the access they need to do their jobs, rather than collecting permissions indefinitely as they move through the business.

In practice, you need to think about things such as:

  • removing accounts belonging to leavers
  • controlling administrative privileges
  • avoiding administrator accounts for normal day-to-day work
  • protecting user accounts appropriately
  • using multi-factor authentication where required

Microsoft 365 also forms part of the picture.

Moving email and files into the cloud does not hand responsibility for account security to Microsoft. Your users, permissions and configuration remain your responsibility.

Malware protection

Devices need suitable protection against malicious software.

Depending on the device and operating system, this can involve anti-malware software, application controls or other permitted approaches under the Cyber Essentials requirements.

In many properly managed Windows environments, much of the technology will already be present.

Certification asks a slightly different question: is that protection configured, maintained and consistently applied across the business?

What is actually in scope for Cyber Essentials certification?

This catches businesses out.

Cyber Essentials covers more than the desktop PCs sitting in your office.

The precise scope depends on how your organisation uses IT, but it can include:

  • laptops and desktops
  • office networks
  • internet-facing routers and firewalls
  • cloud services
  • Microsoft 365
  • tablets and mobile devices
  • user accounts
  • remote-working devices
  • personally owned devices used for work

BYOD is a useful example.

IASME’s current guidance says user-owned devices that access work-related data or services are in scope for Cyber Essentials.

If an employee uses a personal phone to access company email, therefore, the device can be relevant.

Using that same phone purely for voice calls, text messages or an MFA application does not in itself bring the device into scope.

Remote working raises similar questions. Your assessment needs to reflect the systems and devices people genuinely use, rather than the beautifully tidy version everyone wishes they used.

Getting the scope right at the beginning saves problems later.

Excluding the troublesome laptop, unmanaged personal device or cloud service might make the assessment look easier on paper. If employees continue using it to access company data, you haven’t really solved anything.

How difficult is Cyber Essentials for a small subcontractor?

For a reasonably well-run small company, Cyber Essentials should be achievable.

It isn’t automatic.

Often, the obvious technology is already in reasonable shape. Microsoft 365 is in place. Machines run a supported version of Windows. Antivirus is deployed. The business has a decent firewall.

Problems tend to hide in the boring corners.

An old laptop hasn’t been retired.

A former employee still has an active account.

One application has fallen out of vendor support.

Employees have local administrator access they don’t need.

MFA has been rolled out to most people. Most being exactly the sort of word auditors enjoy.

Nobody has a completely reliable device inventory.

Someone accesses business email on an unmanaged personal tablet.

Individually, none sounds particularly dramatic.

Collectively, they tell you quite a lot about how consistently the company’s IT is being managed.

Cyber Essentials is therefore more useful if you regard it as a basic security exercise rather than a certificate you need to make a tender portal happy. The process can expose mundane weaknesses that businesses genuinely ought to fix.

What does Cyber Essentials cost?

Cyber Essentials uses a tiered certification fee based on organisation size.

According to IASME’s current published pricing, the standard Cyber Essentials assessment costs:

  • Micro organisations, 0 to 9 employees: £320 + VAT
  • Small organisations, 10 to 49 employees: £440 + VAT
  • Medium organisations, 50 to 249 employees: £500 + VAT
  • Large organisations, 250+ employees: £600 + VAT

Those figures cover the Cyber Essentials assessment. They shouldn’t be confused with the total cost of getting your business ready.

If your IT already meets the requirements, the additional work may be limited. If the assessment uncovers unsupported hardware, old software, poor account controls or devices that need bringing under management, remediation obviously has a cost.

Buying the assessment also differs from paying a provider to help you prepare, remediate problems and manage the certification process.

Bear that in mind when comparing prices. A low assessment fee tells you what the assessment costs. It doesn’t tell you what getting your business successfully through it will cost.

Why doing Cyber Essentials before the tender makes sense

A live tender is a particularly bad time to discover your IT estate isn’t quite as tidy as everyone thought.

Starting earlier gives you room to establish the scope properly, find what’s missing, fix problems sensibly and complete certification without a procurement deadline hanging over everyone.

Commercially, that gives you:

  • fewer surprises during supplier onboarding
  • less risk of a Cyber Essentials question stopping a PQQ
  • certification ready when an opportunity appears
  • stronger evidence when customers ask about your security
  • known IT weaknesses dealt with before somebody exploits them

Will Cyber Essentials win you a contract?

No.

Price, capability, track record, relationships, capacity and plenty of other factors may decide that.

But if certification is a gateway requirement, failing to have it can stop you reaching the stage where those strengths are considered. For a subcontractor, that’s the commercial case for doing the work early.

Getting help with Cyber Essentials for subcontractors

You can complete Cyber Essentials as a self-assessment, and businesses with well-managed IT may be capable of working through the process themselves.

Where businesses often struggle is determining whether their answers reflect how their technology is actually configured and used.

What exactly is in scope?

Are those personal mobiles relevant?

Is that old application still supported?

Are administrator accounts correctly configured ?

Does your Microsoft 365 environment meet the requirements?

What needs fixing before you submit the assessment?

Cyber Essentials Certification from Your IT Department is designed to help businesses work through those questions practically. We bring every client up to the Cyber Essentials standard, whether they go for the certificate or not because we believe it’s the minimum that a business should have. Your IT are both Cyber Essentials and Cyber Essentials Plus certified ourselves and have staff trained as cyber essentials assesosrs.

We can help you understand the scope, identify gaps, fix technical issues and prepare the business for assessment. We can also make sure the underlying controls don’t disappear the moment the certificate arrives.

Because if larger customers increasingly expect cyber essentials for subcontractors, a live tender is a particularly expensive way to discover that your IT isn’t ready.

Sort it beforehand and the next time a PQQ asks:

“Do you hold Cyber Essentials certification?”

You can answer yes.

Your IT Department Logo